Dear Readers,
I was a weird kid. Or rather, I heard often from many, many people: “You are weird.”
Unfortunately, I heard other things too. But I’ll get to that later.
Back to me being ‘weird.’
I have dyslexia. Like, super hardcore dyslexia. Like I couldn’t read or write when I was 8. Back in the 80’s, when I was a kid, they diagnosed me as “retarded.” This was before a wealth of research had been done on dyslexia, autism, sensory processing disorders, OCD, ADHD, etc. So all kids fell into one basket: Slow. Weird. Retarded.
Words have meaning, we all know this. We know how words can cut and make you bleed. How they leave scars that are unseen. The right words and the wrong words color a person’s perspective for his/her entire life. I know this because I used to come home from school every day with cuts caused by words. How I think, how I respond to life is filtered through my scars.
My most current book, ‘The Cad and the Co-ed’, uses a word that was once applied to me many, many times. It is a word that used to send me home to cry in my bed, believing that I was stupid and worthless.
This word should never be used unless to show that a person is a villain, to demonstrate the depth of that person’s callousness. The problem is, our *hero* used that word. It was a throwaway line, where the hero was referring to himself, which almost makes it worse.
It was written by someone who lives in Ireland (and, believe me, this has been a learning experience for her) I didn’t catch it when I read it 100 times (I’m in the USA). Nor did our editors or proofreaders (located in Australia and Canada). But it’s not their fault, it’s not their job, it’s our job as the authors.
Specifically, it’s my fault. Because words have cultural connotations. This word isn’t applied in the same way in Ireland as it is in the USA. It was my job to catch it and I failed.
When the word was brought to my attention via a private message by a reader less than an hour ago, I was HORRIFIED. I immediately did a word search and found it and all those horrid memories came back.
I was 8 again, crying because I’d been called a “fucktard” by Rhena. She’d whispered it in my ear when she passed. Or Will had said it when he wouldn’t let me sit at his table. Or Kara when she’d passed me a note with a single word which I struggled to decipher.
In the USA, in my cultural experience, this word is not okay. It’s never okay. It’s not a knife, it’s a sword. I know this. I have the scars to prove it. And I will be eternally dismayed and disheartened that it make it into a book that *I* published, as I believe LH is as well.
We write books meant to lift people up, because we *love* love. And this word is only ever used to tear people down.
We’ve already replaced the manuscript file with a corrected one, removing the word. We’re appealing to Amazon Kindle Publishing, asking them to push a replacement of the file ASAP on all devices. I don’t know if we’ll succeed, but I pray that we do.
I apologize. I am so deeply sorry. I hope you can forgive me, but I understand if you cannot. I know what that word feels like to wear. So, I understand if this is something that you cannot look past.
Love, Penny
Thank you so much! Word have powers, your apology has powers too! Taking to bring this issue to notice!
Brilliant! Love love!
Thank you for this. Thank you for being brave enough to share your pain and taking responsibility. Thank you for being a great human being. Much love and respect to you.
Thank you for acknowledging an innocent mistake and I asking steps to correct it. That’s called responsibility and I appreciate your efforts. Your readers know you take the characters who everyone ridicules and makes them our hero or heroine. Thank you.
Thank YOU, I can close my eyes and remember “fatty fatty four eyes” like it was yesterday not 30+ years ago. There is still one girl in HS that I forced myself to forgive but hell I will never forget her name or evil face. My favourite place on earth is teaching in a Spec Ed. classroom. Love the gifted kids, love the kid’s struggling to fit a triangle peg into a circle. Love it even more when when they force it to fit in and the teacher in me turns into a 13 yr old HP obsessed kid. There goes the entire curriculum for the day but those are the days I live for. The days why I remember why I am kicking cancer so hard that I’m thrilled to say chemo 6 is this Thursday. Last one is April 20. All you are guilty of is not noticing something that hurt you so profoundly. Cyber hug and congratulations for once again proving that everyone is perfectly imperfect in their own special way. A non verbal Autistic Gr. 3 student, I had the pleasure of teaching for 8 months is still obsessed with building and creating. If he does not become an architect or CEO of Lego Canada and get paid for it in 16 yrs. Well, he will be doing something equally creative and setting the world on it’s axis for the better. Cant wait to see him Tuesday morning as a Gr 6 student.
Penny, thank you for your honesty. I have a special needs son. I understand. Apology accepted. It will not make me stop reading anything you write.
Your apology is very moving, in that you tell us how hurtfull words can and are used. I don’t remember being called names but I’m sure I was or made fun of. I think, luckily, I’m a positive person; my mother always called me ‘the Unsinkable Molly Brown’. I read your apology to my sister (she has no computer/kindle, etc) and she remembered being called ‘built like a brick ‘s _ _ t’house when she was in 8th grade and was horrified and didn’t go to school the next day. She thought they meant she looked like a pile of ‘s _ _ t’ and belonged in an outhouse. I also think kids do not realize what their words can do to others, well, ok, some DO. When you have a character who is a really horrible person, like Ben , then, yeah, I can see someone like him using a word like your ‘f word, even as an adult. My sister also thought it was worse to be made fun of in public by someone you love or care about (her EX- husband). She ‘got even’ by dumping a glass of ice water in his lap when driving home, but she was still mortified. (Not to mention, the could have ended up in an accident!) I think what kids do to other kids is worse though, because they carry it with them for so long….like you said, in scars. Realistically, people do say crappy things to others…God knows why???
I meant Ben S. from Hypotheses series…which, by the way, I ABSOLUTELY LOOOOVVVEEE!!!
This is one of the most beautiful, humble and sincere apologies I have ever read. That word does not have the same meaning for me (greetings from Holland), but I can nevertheless understand the controverse. Good for you for owning up to a mistake and not glossing over it.
I had dyslexia and one of my daughters has it now. I am about to start reading the book but I get what you are saying. I was lucky that I have always had a fairly high IQ and although no one ever called me that, I was bullied by a group of mean girls because I was smart and did well in school….also i the 80s. I think that people need to understand that they are reading fiction. I am not as thick skinned as I should be but thank you for your apology. It shows what a truly wonderful person you are.
Thank you! That was beautifully written and so sincere.
#foreverloyalfan
Also, please add more books to kindleunlimited – I want to share them with everyone I know!
Hi,
I’m an anonymous person of the internet. My opinions do not inform your decisions. I know this. That said, I hope you can hear this:
If you haven’t already, please forgive yourself.
This was a fail pretty much all around. Some people may be hurt. That word adds something to the world that perhaps you’d rather surgically remove. I can’t imagine how that might feel. I do understand the need to make amends, though, given some of the colossal screw-ups I’ve made in my own life.
So, even though I’m an anonymous person of the internet, thank you for your apology. I hope writing your apology helped to give you peace. I hope my words help that peace reverberate.
You’re a wonderful writer. Thank you for the many, many good, positive, beautiful, funny words you’ve put into the world. Your characters make me feel less alone in the world. The worlds you’ve created are comfortable ones to be in, like slipping into a favorite sweater in an alpaca-cashmere blend that magically never, ever sags at the seams.
And that is a wonderful thing to add to this world.
Thank you!!
You are one of my MOST favorite authors. I LOVE to read. Sharing about your dyslexia and your experience growing up warms my hopeful ‘mommy’ heart! My daughter is 11 and struggles daily with dyslexia, reading, and feeling good about herself. You are an inspiration!
Thank you!!
I’m weird. Of course I’m my own unique form of weird but before I started reading your books my ability to be this strange creature was something that troubled me. The ‘dorky/nerdy’ outsiders looked at me like an enigma. I started with ‘neanderthal seeks human’ I love your characters, I began to love weird. Thank you for being youxx.
We can all be weird together! The word surprised me when I read the book. It just didn’t “feel” like you and now I definitely know that it is not you. You must be so proud of your accomplishments and the many positive characters you have created. Mistakes happen, admitting them is brave and working to correct them is so admirable! Please keep on being Penny! We love you!
When I grow up, I hope that I can be as brave and as talented as you are! You are a daily inspiration. Thank you!
I enjoy your books. They were included in my library for audible, but now I am hooked. I love the fact that all the leading ladies are a bit nerdy and dilfferent. The characters are ridiculous, but relateable. They also have a enviable circle of friends knitting them together. Thanks for the Happily Ever Afters for the “Wierd” girls ! xoxo